21 comments

This signed Neil Armstrong photograph, listed on eBay, and based on an online opinion from PSA, came back as " LIKELY NOT AUTHENTIC " .This item comes with a Steven Zarelli COA.

It Was Steve Zarelli, who stated on AML that PSA has a " Hair Trigger" on the likely not authentic opinion. So - my next question is -who is right ?

Steve Zarelli is cuter than Steve Grad.I would never want to rub my sword against Steve Grad, but *** Pride Aside, Steve Zarelli just does not match up to Grad's experience, so I have to go with the opinion of PSA.

Review about: Signed Neil Armstrong Photo.

Review #472992 is a subjective opinion of a user.

PRODUCT OR SERVICE
Not specified
Reason of Review / Monetary Loss Not specified / $1200
Preferred solution Not specified

Had an Experience with Ebay?

Submit review

Comments

Comment as anonymous or
Terms of Service
Post Comment
Cancel
Steve
Nutley, New Jersey, United States #860980
This is an obvious forgery-makes me wonder. Did Zarelli really authenticate this or did some dumdum print up a fake Zarelli COA to go with the forgery.
Anonymous
to Steve #863811
I am afraid that Mr. Zarelli is the dumdum
Nick
#858981
Another example of Steve Zarelli's Expertise !!!!!!!
Gerry
#845200
Steve Zarelli has not impressed me. Usually if Steven Zarelli reviewed and gave it a COA then I give it greater scrutiny . He makes mistakes and collectors are going get discouraged upon discovering they have bad material in ,lets say 3-10 years.
Marc
to Gerry #847133
I share in your opinion
Hunt
#837290
Zarelli's so-called expertise falls into question when examples like this one surface. I recommend buying from reputable dealers that offer a written guarantee and buy the best items you can afford from such dealers and don't waste $ 100 on a worthless COA and instead spend more on the item and buy from established dealers. Zarelli is not going to refund your money in 5-10 years, in fact the fine print on his COA's have a legal disclaimer.
Buy smart and do not waste money on third party COAs.
CXCY
Exeter, Rhode Island, United States #831260
I agree that Mr Zarelli's expertize may have been grossly exaggerated and Grad has more experience but don't forget that Grad has some baggage as well. Grad worked closely alongside Bill Mastro for years and now Mastro has been indicted on fraud charges. I don't really care which one is "cuter" and the OP should remove that part of the post.
UACC Member
Washington, District Of Columbia, United States #827779
Beware of autograph sellers offering a "Certificate of Authenticity". They are absolutely worthless. If you will fake and autograph you will fake a COA.
Most reputable autograph dealers will not offer COA's but instead offer a lifetime unconditional guarantee. If you are unhappy, simply return the item is the condition it was sold to you.
You will see sellers offering guarantees that run out in 7 days, 10 days, 30 days, etc. That should be unacceptable to you as a buyer.
Some sellers will state that a questionable signature cannot be returned without it being authenticated by an expert. They know that this is VERY expensive to do. To get a signature authenticated will often run in to hundreds of dollars. These sellers know that no one will go to that trouble for an autograph that was bought for under that amount.
The Universal Autograph Collector's Club (UACC), one of the most - if not THE most respected autograph organizations in the world, have long renounced the use of COA's. Here are a few FAQ's straight from their web site:
Q: Are Certificates of Authenticity endorsed by the UACC? A: The UACC has been very vocal about the fact that Certificates of Authenticity (COA's for short) are totally worthless. The UACC does not issue COA's and always encourgae collectors to get a signed receipt for merchandise, instead of a COA. Frankly, they aren't worth the paper they are printed on. A COA is only as good as the dealer that has issued it. If you buy from a UACC
... Show more
Famous Doug Robinson
#823910
The signature seems to be on part of the flag ! What about the Flag test ?
Gerry Salidine MD
Utica, New York, United States #814027
PSA does not have a so-called hair trigger on autographs, they are correct most of the time unlike individuals who pass themselves off as experts and cause some collectors to destroy real autographs while causing other collectors to spend good money on fakes. I would trust PSA 100% while giving Steve Zarelli the golden raspberry because he does not have the same training or knowledge as Steve Grad and that is my opinion on the matter

You May Also Like

"IncidentI purchased a Red and black contemporary sofa from LA furniture via ebay! I called prior to purchase to confirm the red was primary red rather than some off color...." Read more
"I am a teacher and I have been working on a 6-month project to bring a new class to our local public school. I had purchased from this seller tlj_emporium..." Read more
"I bought this ring to give to my wife on Mothers Day 2016. A week after I gave it to her she showed me the spots under the stone...." Read more
"I want to say i was excited when i rolled across this karenbarn ,but behold i did not know i was buying a box of junk ... I should have listen..." Read more
"Chantelle owes in excess of $30000 for back child support and is wanted by the Texas Attorney General's Office. There is warrant for her arrest. Her aliases include; Alley Kaitschuck,..." Read more
"I would simply say "run away". I would have never bought from DR Horton had I looked at the reviews prior to buying. So far all reviews have been dead..." Read more
"Got a ring for my sister's birthday because she's a huge jewellery collector I know. The product is sparkling and my sister loves it. The product which we received was..." Read more
"I purchased this approximately 6 years ago. The set consists of a sofa, recliner, chair and ottoman. I notified Ashley Furniture customer support 2 years ago that my furniture started..." Read more